Sicily's Best Pizzeria & Restaurant

190 Cypress Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11237 Order now

Order Online Today!

quotation

Our reviews

Reviews from Grubhub

Sicily's Best Pizzeria & Restaurant Reviews on Grubhub

Melissa

1 review
Sicily's Best Pizza has been a reliably great place to order pizza delivery for years--a couple delivery people had a tough time with our stairs, but . (We've been here nearly 12... food is consistently good.) Beware they're closed for a couple weeks in the Fall--in August I think? The baked clams are sinfully delicious, and the pizzas are always good. We've ordered sandwiches which were also nice. All in all, a great place that's been a part of our 'hood for a long time and we always order from them when we want good pizza.

Paola

Top Reviewer
The delivery was like 25 minutes early which I honetly don't mind one bit. The pizza, cheese sticks and garlic knots were great, hot and cold the next day. That says alot right there. Wish the pizza had more thickness to it maybe a bit more sauce or a ticker crust but it was still delicious and will definitely order from here again.

Lydia

Top Reviewer
The best place is the best place to order from. The food is always delivered earlier than expected, super hot, fresh and more importantly delicious. I order here often and have never had a problem. I wish other restaurants would take their approach on great customer service.

Michael

Top Reviewer
I've eaten here many a time and it never ceases to amaze. The regular cheese pie is on the higher end of my favorite pizzas in NY, and the Grandma Pie isn't what it was 2-3 years ago but is still dope, plus the delivery guy is fast and polite.

Miguel

1 review
The buffalo wings are amazing. The pepperoni bites a little bit too much garlic but if you eat it while it's really hot taste really good. Want the fries a little more salt but other than that was really good and came earlier than supposed to.

Reviews from Seamless.com

Sicily's Best Pizzeria & Restaurant Reviews on Seamless

megan

Top Reviewer
I'm not even done eating but I couldn't really wait to say something good about this place.
I don't find a lot of good Italian in Bushwick. Definitely not a lot of good service.
This food was BANGING. Absolutely delicious.
Fast delivery. Very nice delivery guy.
I got two slices, mozz sticks and garlic knots.
Everything was hot, fresh the knots are next level.
They didn't even charge for the little cup of sauce with it.

New go to in town. <3

Ester

1 review
Delivery was a little early which is alwayyys a plus because Im always ordering when Im hungry. I did order a lot of food (garlic knots, buffalo wings, pepperoni pizza) for myself (Im greedy when it comes to eating more than I can handle). But I can always have them for lunch and dinner the next few days. Delivery man was professional checked my order. Regret not giving him a cash tip since the weather has been horrible the last few days!

Jacqueline Spindola

Top Reviewer
This place is perfect. I LOVE their lasagna!!!! It's really saucy and cheesy and meaty and delicious. The pizza is great too, it's about on par with something like Joe's Pizza in the city but even better imo.

My order is always on time (or early!!!) and hot and freshhhhh. Love this place. They never forget the ranch dressing either, haha.

Sean

4 reviews
First of all: I accidentally placed a pick-up order instead of delivery. After I informed them of my error they still delivered it to me quickly. Really great customer service. Pizza was really solid, delivered warm with a soft crust. Blown away by the garlic bread, which was consumed quickly. Very pleased with the order.

Molly

2 reviews
We got the everyday special which came with a cheese pizza (we upgraded to 1 topping), garlic knots, and a two liter of soda. The food was super tasty! The pizza was exceptionally flavorful and yummy. Delivery guy was polite and the food was delivered quickly. I do wish they had more pizza topping choices, though.

About us

Calzones, Chicken, Dinner, Family Combo, Italian, Lunch, Lunch Specials, Pasta, Pizza, Salads, Sandwiches, Seafood, Subs
Today

Here at Sicily's, Italian food is made with the finest ingredients, lovingly prepared by a staff that considers cooking an art. Every meal at Sicily's is prepared in the Italian tradition of "Buon Gusto. "Your Hosts-Gaspar, Maria & Giovanna